We've been considering removing workspace-hack for a couple reasons:
- Lukas ran into a situation where its build script seemed to be causing
spurious rebuilds. This seems more likely to be a cargo bug than an
issue with workspace-hack itself (given that it has an empty build
script), but we don't necessarily want to take the time to hunt that
down right now.
- Marshall mentioned hakari interacts poorly with automated crate
updates (in our case provided by rennovate) because you'd need to have
`cargo hakari generate && cargo hakari manage-deps` after their changes
and we prefer to not have actions that make commits.
Currently removing workspace-hack causes our workspace to grow from
~1700 to ~2000 crates being built (depending on platform), which is
mainly a problem when you're building the whole workspace or running
tests across the the normal and remote binaries (which is where
feature-unification nets us the most sharing). It doesn't impact
incremental times noticeably when you're just iterating on `-p zed`, and
we'll hopefully get these savings back in the future when
rust-lang/cargo#14774 (which re-implements the functionality of hakari)
is finished.
Release Notes:
- N/A
Co-Authored-By: Ben K <ben@zed.dev>
Co-Authored-By: Anthony <anthony@zed.dev>
Co-Authored-By: Mikayla <mikayla@zed.dev>
Release Notes:
- settings: Major internal changes to settings. The primary user-facing
effect is that some settings which did not make sense in project
settings files are no-longer read from there. (For example the inline
blame settings)
---------
Co-authored-by: Ben Kunkle <ben@zed.dev>
Co-authored-by: Mikayla Maki <mikayla.c.maki@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Anthony <anthony@zed.dev>
Supersedes: #34500
Also this will allow to fix this: #35386 without the UX changes but
providers can now be control through settings as well within zed.
Just rebased the latest main and docs added. Added @AurelienTollard as
co-author as it was started by him everything else remains the same from
original PR.
Release Notes:
- Added ability to control Provider Routing for OpenRouter models from
settings.
Co-authored-by: Aurelien Tollard <tollard.aurelien1999@gmail.com>
Improves the error handling for openrouter and adds automatic retry like
anthropic for few of the status codes.
Release Notes:
- Improves error messages for Openrouter provider
- Automatic retry when rate limited or Server error from Openrouter
This pull request adds full integration with OpenRouter, allowing users
to access a wide variety of language models through a single API key.
**Implementation Details:**
* **Provider Registration:** Registers OpenRouter as a new language
model provider within the application's model registry. This includes UI
for API key authentication, token counting, streaming completions, and
tool-call handling.
* **Dedicated Crate:** Adds a new `open_router` crate to manage
interactions with the OpenRouter HTTP API, including model discovery and
streaming helpers.
* **UI & Configuration:** Extends workspace manifests, the settings
schema, icons, and default configurations to surface the OpenRouter
provider and its settings within the UI.
* **Readability:** Reformats JSON arrays within the settings files for
improved readability.
**Design Decisions & Discussion Points:**
* **Code Reuse:** I leveraged much of the existing logic from the
`openai` provider integration due to the significant similarities
between the OpenAI and OpenRouter API specifications.
* **Default Model:** I set the default model to `openrouter/auto`. This
model automatically routes user prompts to the most suitable underlying
model on OpenRouter, providing a convenient starting point.
* **Model Population Strategy:**
* <strike>I've implemented dynamic population of available models by
querying the OpenRouter API upon initialization.
* Currently, this involves three separate API calls: one for all models,
one for tool-use models, and one for models good at programming.
* The data from the tool-use API call sets a `tool_use` flag for
relevant models.
* The data from the programming models API call is used to sort the
list, prioritizing coding-focused models in the dropdown.</strike>
* <strike>**Feedback Welcome:** I acknowledge this multi-call approach
is API-intensive. I am open to feedback and alternative implementation
suggestions if the team believes this can be optimized.</strike>
* **Update: Now this has been simplified to one api call.**
* **UI/UX Considerations:**
* <strike>Authentication Method: Currently, I've implemented the
standard API key input in settings, similar to other providers like
OpenAI/Anthropic. However, OpenRouter also supports OAuth 2.0 with PKCE.
This could offer a potentially smoother, more integrated setup
experience for users (e.g., clicking a button to authorize instead of
copy-pasting a key). Should we prioritize implementing OAuth PKCE now,
or perhaps add it as an alternative option later?</strike>(PKCE is not
straight forward and complicated so skipping this for now. So that we
can add the support and work on this later.)
* <strike>To visually distinguish models better suited for programming,
I've considered adding a marker (e.g., `</>` or `🧠`) next to their
names. Thoughts on this proposal?</strike>. (This will require a changes
and discussion across model provider. This doesn't fall under the scope
of current PR).
* OpenRouter offers 300+ models. The current implementation loads all of
them. **Feedback Needed:** Should we refine this list or implement more
sophisticated filtering/categorization for better usability?
**Motivation:**
This integration directly addresses one of the most highly upvoted
feature requests/discussions within the Zed community. Adding OpenRouter
support significantly expands the range of AI models accessible to
users.
I welcome feedback from the Zed team on this implementation and the
design choices made. I am eager to refine this feature and make it
available to users.
ISSUES: https://github.com/zed-industries/zed/discussions/16576
Release Notes:
- Added support for OpenRouter as a language model provider.
---------
Signed-off-by: Umesh Yadav <umesh4257@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Marshall Bowers <git@maxdeviant.com>
